Feature

Europe puts Norway’s power system to the test


Claude Olsen

On days with little wind, Europe may have to rely on Norwegian reservoirs to keep its wheels running smoothly in the future. On the Continent, the concept of Norway as Europe’s green battery has caught on – but is it feasible in practice?

The Centre for Environmental Design of Renewable Energy (CEDREN) – one of Norway’s Centres for Environment-friendly Energy Research – is carrying out the HydroPEAK project to study whether Norway could truly provide Europe’s balance power.

When electricity production is based on intermittent sources such as the sun and wind, the power delivered to the grid will vary greatly from hour to hour and from day to night. Consumers, however, expect a constant supply of electricity on the grid, whether during periods of peak demand in the morning and afternoon or periods of low demand at night.

Flexible hydropower

The imbalance between the supply of power and consumer demand is becoming more and more of a problem for energy companies and grid operators, as fossil fuel-based power plants are gradually being replaced by wind farms. Norway’s main energy source, hydropower, is unique in that production can easily be adjusted by releasing more or less water through the turbines.

Since Norway has Europe’s largest hydropower resources, the Continent’s energy companies and grid operators are keenly interested in gaining access to Norwegian reservoirs. The question is, will Norway be able to help Europe with its balance power needs?

Demand exceeds supply

A recent study by the German Advisory Council on the Environment reports that Germany’s target to produce all of its electricity from renewable sources by 2050 hinges upon access to a whopping 60 GW of balance power.

The study identifies Norway as the only country that could supply such a volume. This amount, however, is several times greater than Norway’s potential as estimated by the Norwegian Water Resources and Energy Directorate (NVE). According to NVE, Norway’s potential for balance power production in 2030 will total some 20 GW. By way of comparison, Norway’s total installed capacity is currently 29 GW.

Rapid changes in the power system

The greatest challenge, however, is not the scale of Europe’s balance power needs, but rather the rapid changes that are putting Norway’s entire power system under pressure, from changes in the reservoirs’ biological environments to voltage fluctuations in the grid.

Reservoir levels can vary by as much as 10 metres in a single day, and voltage fluctuations in the grid can overload consumers’ electrical devices. This is where Norwegian researchers enter the picture.

Important basic research

The HydroPEAK project is one of 7 main areas of focus at CEDREN.

“In the HydroPEAK project, we are conducting vital basic research to facilitate development of a large-scale European network with a substantial proportion of wind power,” says project manager Ånund Killingtveit.

Professor Killingtveit of the Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU) heads a large group of researchers working in eight different fields. Together they seek solutions to the challenges that major, rapid fluctuations in power production pose to Norway’s hydropower plants and national grid.

Numerous challenges

The HydroPEAK project addresses 8 areas of research:

  • scenarios for Europe’s balance power needs;
  • hydrological effects;
  • models for the power system;
  • pumped-storage hydroelectric stations;
  • frequency variations in the grid;
  • physical effects on hydro tunnels;
  • physical effects on rivers;
  • impacts on river ice.

The first area listed above provides a basis for all of the HydroPEAK sub-projects. Researchers are drawing up scenarios for how the Norwegian energy sector could satisfy the balance power demands of a European power system that will be increasingly based on renewable energy.

“The scenarios determine how much balance power will be needed, so that the other research areas can be scaled according to the most likely scenarios,” explains Professor Killingtveit.

Changes in Norwegian watercourses

Norway has in-depth expertise in the environmentally-responsible operation of hydropower plants. So far, changes have mostly occurred gradually over long periods of time. However, the power system of tomorrow will have to absorb rapid change, which may lead to some unpleasant surprises.

One consequence will be more difficulty in delivering electricity with stable voltage and frequency. Also, hydro tunnels for transporting water from the reservoir to the turbines may be exposed to a higher risk of rockslides and landslides due to greater variation in water pressure in the rock.

“Using the Norwegian power system for balance power will lead to changes in Norway’s watercourses. How much are we willing to tolerate?” ask the professor and his colleagues.

Reprinted with the kind permission of the Research Council of Norway. Written by Claude Olsen.

Share this article

More services

 

This article is featured in:
Energy infrastructure

 

Comments

peterh said

15 November 2010
For starters, surely france and other players will have significant and greater nuclear power supply. as already indicated, seden supplies nuclear power to Norway anyway. ALL sources will have a role to play in meeting the energy demand.

Dr Troncoso said

04 November 2010
Interesting project and worrying situation at the same time.

Indeed the power industry in Europe is well aware of the problems imposed by high wind penetrations and yet they seem to be waiting for some sort of "magic" solution (at "super low cost").

Our renewable resources (unfortunately intermittent) are large and there exist a range of energy storage technologies that inevitably will have to participate in our power/energy systems, namely batteries (stationary or PHEVs), storage in the form of hydrogen (highly versatile), flywheels, capacitors, or flow batteries to name a few.
Also development of active load management mechanisms (e.g. via batteries or using electrolysis plant as controllable loads) is a must.
It is common knowledge within the industry that integrating large wind penetrations into power systems without large interconnections and energy storage is unfeasible (both technically and economically). The remaining question is then what “large penetrations” means. A matter for detailed region-specific analysis.

So more initiatives like these projects are required. Potential solutions are out there but some need to be developed and/or optimized further. What are we waiting for?

Dr Troncoso said

04 November 2010

Incoteco said

04 November 2010
I am glad that someone with some technical authority has at last "bitten the bullet" and exposed the myth that Norwegian hydro can balance a "renewable" Europe. A myth it is.

Norway is already a very satisfactory, if quite expensive 4 GW battery for Danish wind power and may be similar balancing services can be extended to parts of Germany and the Netherlands. But as the current dry winter is proving, its reservoirs can fall to dangerously low levels when Norway will be very glad for imports of coal energy from Denmark and nuclear power from Sweden.

European demand is 600 GW. May I propose that if they really want to introduce more intermittent energy into Europe, its enthusiasts should embrace the idea (and implementation) of widely distributed storage such is offered by the company that I represent in Europe, being www.pdenergy.com.

Hugh Sharman
Hugh.Sharman@pdenergy.com
T +45 9825 1760
Cell +45 4055 1760

Note: The majority of comments posted are created by members of the public. The views expressed are theirs and unless specifically stated are not those Elsevier Ltd. We are not responsible for any content posted by members of the public or content of any third party sites that are accessible through this site. Any links to third party websites from this website do not amount to any endorsement of that site by the Elsevier Ltd and any use of that site by you is at your own risk. For further information, please refer to our Terms & Conditions.

Comment on this article

You must be registered and logged in to leave a comment about this article.